Posts Tagged ‘bankruptcy study’

A study recently published by the web site Find Law indicates that a considerable percentage of the U.S. population (one in eight survey respondents, or nearly 13 percent) has either considered filing for bankruptcy or actually done so.

That figure may seem high, but in a nation of consumer debt, depreciating home values and a limited job market, perhaps it’s no wonder that so many of us are in need of serious the serious financial protection and debt relief that bankruptcy can offer.

Who Is Considering Bankruptcy?

The study breaks down potential bankruptcy filers in part by age:

  • Americans between 35 and 54 are reportedly the group most likely to consider bankruptcy as an option.
  • Americans 18 – 34 and 55 and older are, according to sources, half as likely as the middle age group to consider or actually file for bankruptcy.
  • Senior citizens (those 65 and older) are apparently the least likely group to consider bankruptcy as a debt relief option, at only seven percent.

How Have Bankruptcy Filing Numbers Changed in Recent Years?

Sources indicate that in 2010, 1.5 million Americans actually filed for bankruptcy protection. This number marks the highest annual total since 2005, when the Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act (BAPCPA) took effect and tightened the standards for those interested in bankruptcy protection.

Why Do So Many People Need Bankruptcy Protection?

While no two bankruptcy cases are alike, bankruptcy filers often note common triggers that led them to seek the protection of the bankruptcy court. These include:

  • Unexpected medical expenses: Illness and injury can both cause serious medical bills to build up, particularly for those people who are uninsured or underinsured. And even an otherwise happy event, like the birth of a child, can prove very expensive.
  • Change in family makeup: Divorce and death are difficult to deal with on their own, but are often compounded by the financial troubles they cause. Many families are forced to face unpleasant financial realities after divorce or death carries off a primary breadwinner.
  • Job loss or reduction: Even good employees are at risk of losing their jobs in the current economic climate, and even though layoffs have slowed in recent months, the unemployment rate remains high. It’s no secret that this type of financial burden can lead a household to seek bankruptcy protection.
  • Fear of foreclosure: Even those with good health and steady jobs may find themselves unable to keep up with their mortgage, and some families opt to file for bankruptcy in hopes of fending off mortgage foreclosure.

Considering the many factors that can contribute to a household’s decision to file for bankruptcy protection, it may be a wonder that only one in eight Americans has thought about personal bankruptcy!

A recent study released by the Woodstock Institute of Chicago shows some strange numbers about bankruptcy filings and race. Specifically, the study shows that African American bankruptcy filers choose Chapter 13 bankruptcy more frequently than their white peers.

The implications of this finding are interesting and instructive to anyone considering bankruptcy as a way of easing debt.

Chapter 13 vs. Chapter 7: What’s the Difference?

In order to understand why this study’s findings matter, it’s essential to understand the key differences between Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 bankruptcy.

  • Chapter 7 bankruptcy is designed to offer filers a full discharge of eligible unsecured debt. In order to qualify, filers must pass a means test showing that they do not have sufficient income to make regular payments according to a Chapter 13 repayment plan. Chapter 7 often works well for low-income filers who don’t have very much non-exempt property.
  • Chapter 13 bankruptcy is designed to help those with a regular income repay a portion of their debts. Chapter 13 filers follow a three- to five-year repayment plan in order to catch up on money they owe. At the end of this period, remaining unsecured debts may be discharged by the court.

Choosing the Right Chapter Matters

The study apparently found that blacks and whites of equal income levels were choosing bankruptcy chapters in different proportions. Specifically, sources indicate that in predominately black areas, about 47.9 percent of filers choose Chapter 13 bankruptcy and in predominately white areas, only 22.5 percent of filers do. Nationwide, the rate is 32.8 percent.

Some sources suggest the difference may have been caused in part by overly aggressive advertising by certain bankruptcy firms who were targeting filers in specific areas. These firms, it seems, may have earned more money by leading filers toward Chapter 13 even when they could have filed for Chapter 7.

And the consequences for filing for Chapter 13 when you qualify for Chapter 7 could be serious:

  • Strained finances: Those who qualify for Chapter 7 protection may just barely make enough money to make payments in the Chapter 13 repayment plan, which could harm their ability to save money for emergencies.
  • Prolonged debt: Rather than moving through a quick, four- to six-month Chapter 7 case and ending with a debt discharge, Chapter 13 filers must wait for several years before their debts are cleared. In that time, missing a payment could cause the court to remove its protection.
  • Few benefits: Those who do not have significant non-exempt property may have little or nothing to gain from filing for Chapter 13 when they qualify for Chapter 7.

Deciding which type of bankruptcy makes the most sense for your situation can make a huge difference to your financial future. If you’re considering a bankruptcy filing, be sure to consult with a bankruptcy lawyer about your options.

Harvard Law Professor Elizabeth Warren and the other professionals affiliated with the Consumer Bankruptcy Project have collected significant data about the American families who file for bankruptcy protection and the reasons they file.

That data has been crucial in painting an accurate picture of the average American bankruptcy petitioner that stands in sharp contrast to the "deadbeat" portrait painted by the credit industry and presumed by the 2005 bankruptcy reforms.  You may even have seen Professor Warren on PBS recently, talking about debt in America, or on "20/20".

Now, the Consumer Bankruptcy Project is expanding its scope, and for the first time reaching for a national sample in its research.  That means bankruptcy petitioners across the country may be contacted or receive a Consumer Bankruptcy Project questionnaire.  If you've filed, or file, for bankruptcy protection and you receive the questionnaire, please consider participating in this important study.

Professor Warren assures us that the study has been approved by the human subjects review boards of several Universities and that all responses will be confidential.