Posts Tagged ‘chapter 13 bankruptcy’

The Federal Reserve has proposed a troubling change that could all but eliminate one tool homeowners have to fight mortgage foreclosure, a recent post from Credit.com's blog highlights. The tool is called rescission. Here’s what it is and what might happen to it.

What Is Rescission?

Rescission is a process that more or less offers homeowners a chance to get out of a mortgage if they can prove it was fraudulently or deceptively originated. Specifically:

  • Deceptive & fraudulent mortgage lending: One phenomenon reported frequently during the subprime housing boom of a few years ago was lenders who allegedly lied about specific terms of mortgage loans (whether that meant concealing balloon payments, misrepresenting the nature of adjustable rate mortgages or something else), or encouraged borrowers to do so (usually by inflating their income level). Unsurprisingly, many borrowers who signed such mortgages ended up unable to make payments at some point.
  • Beginning of the foreclosure process: After a few months of failing to make mortgage payments, most homeowners will receive notice from their lenders of foreclosure proceedings. Naturally, this is not pleasant for anyone and can lead to serious stress and financial trouble for affected families.
  • Limited protections in Chapter 13 bankruptcy: While some homeowners are able to find relief from foreclosure proceedings in bankruptcy court, many others find that bankruptcy only addresses some of their problems – after all, the bankruptcy court cannot modify the terms of a mortgage loan.
  • Rescission’s foreclosure prevention: One of the few options available to many homeowners facing foreclosure, then, has been the process of rescission, which works like this: if a homeowner provides a written statement to his lender that his loan was originated fraudulently and can prove as much in court, the court may rule to cancel the terms of the current mortgage. The borrower can then take on a different loan from a different lender to repay the balance to the original creditor.

Essentially, the process of rescission allows homeowners to trade out fraudulent mortgage loans for more affordable, honestly originated ones.

The Fed’s Proposal to Change Rescission

But, as CreditBloggers reports, the Federal Reserve has proposed a change to the rescission laws that would require mortgage borrowers to repay the entirety of their fraudulent mortgage loans and only then challenge the loan’s legality.

As many consumer advocates have pointed out, this would remove much of the foreclosure-prevention potential the current rescission process offers and would prevent most ordinary homeowners from hanging on to their houses.

To learn more about the proposed rule change and the consumer advocates fighting against it, please visit the article linked to above. To learn more about your potential for relieving your mortgage debt with rescission, contact a lawyer in your area.

Personal bankruptcy filings for the month of May have increased compared with a year ago, but dropped slightly compared with a month earlier, the American Bankruptcy Institute reported last week.

Here’s a breakdown of the data.

  • Total filings: In May 2010, 136,142 personal bankruptcy cases were filed, a nine percent increase from May 2009, when 124,838 cases were filed.
  • Month-to-month change: May’s total marked a six percent drop from April of this year, when 144,490 cases were filed.
  • Distribution: Of the cases filed, 26 percent were under Chapter 13 of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code, and most of the remaining 74 percent were under Chapter 7.
  • Projected total: Based on figures collected so far this year, most sources estimate that personal bankruptcy filings this year will total about 1.6 million, a 10 percent increase over the 1.44 million filed in 2009.

So what can these numbers tell us about the economic situation in the U.S.? Let’s take a look.

The Effect of Unemployment

While the decrease in filings from last month can be seen as good news, the increase from this time last year could be read in just the opposite way, meaning that these bankruptcy figures provide no clearer picture of the economic situation than any other economic indicator.

  • Long-term unemployment: The year-to-year increase we see in bankruptcy filings could be one of the effects that the nearly consistent unemployment rate has had—people who have been out of work for several months may have depleted their cash reserves and be turning to bankruptcy for financial relief.
  • Chapter 7 vs. Chapter 13: Another indicator that unemployment is hurting the country is that Chapter 7 cases outnumber Chapter 13 cases nearly two to one, indicating that most people in financial distress cannot afford repayment plans to resolve their outstanding debts and have relatively little income.
  • The role of mortgages: In addition to the problem of unemployment, mortgage costs may be pushing more filers toward Chapter 7. Despite the Obama Administration’s Home Affordable Modification Program (HAMP), millions of Americans with unaffordable mortgage loans have not been able to have their loans modified, meaning that they’re stuck with expensive (and, in many cases, too expensive) mortgage payments.

If you’re struggling with unwieldy debt, an unmanageable mortgage or other financial burdens, you may want to consider consulting with a bankruptcy attorney from your area to see whether personal bankruptcy protection is right for you.

For most of us, the story of how the Great Recession started is a familiar tune: the stock market soared because of speculation on the real estate market, which meant real estate prices soared as well. And when the bubble burst, millions of Americans lost serious money and bankruptcy and foreclosure rates climbed steadily.

And the latest news, according to real estate information source Zillow.com, still reflects a seriously distressed housing market in many parts of the country.

Underwater Homes

One of the biggest problems homeowners face today is negative equity: when you owe more on a home loan than the property is currently worth, you’re said to have negative equity, or be “underwater” on your mortgage loan.

According to sources, a whopping 23.3 percent of U.S. homes are currently underwater, slightly more than the 23 percent reported in the last quarter of 2009. Here’s a look at the U.S. cities currently suffering from the highest negative home equity rates:

  • #15: Jacksonville, Florida. Here, 127,807 homes, or 49.1 percent of residences, are currently underwater.
  • #14: Riverside, California. This city has a 51.2 percent underwater rate, with 347,778 individual homes.
  • #13: Tampa, Florida. 286,303 underwater homes give this city a 53.1 percent rate.
  • #12: Vallejo, California. With 41,436 homes underwater, this city has a 54.7 percent rate.
  • #11: El Centro, California. A 54.9 percent rate means 12,103 houses in this city are underwater.
  • #10: Port St. Lucie, Florida. With 54,190 homes underwater, this city has a 56.2 percent rate.
  • #9: Stockton, California. Once the foreclosure capital of the country, this city now has the dubious distinction of a 57.7 percent underwater rate, with 64,614 homes underwater.
  • #8: Fort Meyers, Florida. Here, 58.2 percent of homes (83,533) have negative equity.
  • #7: Lakeland, Florida. With 62,423 homes underwater, this city has a 58.5 percent rate.
  • #6: Merced, California. 24,076 underwater homes, for a rate of 58.8 percent.
  • #5: Modesto, California. A 60.7 percent rate with 54,417 homes underwater.
  • #4: Reno, Nevada. 45,107 homes underwater gives Reno a 64.4 percent rate.
  • #3: Phoenix, Arizona. Here, 64.4 percent of homes (totaling 479,692) have negative equity.
  • #2: Orlando, Florida. With 289,209 homes underwater, Orlando has a 74.8 percent rate.
  • #1: Las Vegas, Nevada. A whopping 80.6 percent of homes (254,880) have negative equity.

Negative equity is no small matter for affected homeowners, considering that mortgage modifications have been difficult to process and foreclosure is generally a trying process.

For some people facing foreclosure of their homes, a Chapter 13 bankruptcy filing may help, but it may not help the problem of owing more on a house than it's worth.

If you have negative equity in your home, consider speaking with a personal bankruptcy lawyer about your options.

Tuesday, January 12th, 2010

Medical Records in Bankruptcy Court

A recent report from the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel Online describes a potential complication that might arise during a bankruptcy filing. Here’s a look at what happened and what it might mean for other filers.

Your Records in Chapter 13 Bankruptcy

When you file for Chapter 13 bankruptcy, you’re agreeing to the following:

  • Committing to a repayment plan that lasts three to five years and satisfies part or all of your secured debt
  • Completing two courses (the pre-filing credit counseling briefing and the pre-discharge debtor education course) designed to help you improve your relationship with money and credit
  • Making public your records of debts and payments

It’s the last item on this list that has proved problematic. In the case of some Wisconsin bankruptcy petitioners, it seems, debt and payment information in medical bills that became part of the public record included details about doctor’s visits, procedures and medicines they used.

Now, according to sources, several Wisconsin residents have filed class-action lawsuits in state and federal court against Aurora Health Care Inc., the company reportedly responsible for submitting the detailed medical information.

Beyond Embarrassment

Bankruptcy filers who see their medical history become part of public record may have reason for embarrassment, but, according to reports, that isn’t the only reason this lawsuit has gotten attention.

Certain information (for instance, about treatment for past injuries) could prevent a filer from getting hired at a job in the future or pave the way to medical identity theft. And privacy laws often protect the disclosure of such information.

Should You Be Worried?

The good news here is that, while medical records included as part of a bankruptcy filing may have the potential to hurt your career or cause you embarrassment, the odds of anyone besides your lawyer, your bankruptcy trustee and the judge on your case seeing them is slim.

After all, such information appears as part of the loads of paperwork involved with filing a bankruptcy petition – sifting through to find such details would be a daunting task.

Still, this story highlights one more reason why enlisting the help of an attorney when you decide to file for bankruptcy protection can be a crucial element of making sure you receive the protection and fresh financial start you’re seeking.

The U.S. Supreme Court began hearing today the case involving a debtor whose student loans were discharged in a Chapter 13 bankruptcy—though possibly against the U.S. Bankruptcy Code.

Student loans are notorious for being difficult to discharge in bankruptcy, even in a Chapter 13 bankruptcy. In order to have student loan debt eliminated, a debtor must prove undue hardship.

In the case before the Supreme Court, the debtor, Francisco Espinosa, was allowed to enter a Chapter 13 plan without ever proving undue hardship to the bankruptcy court, according to a story on National Public Radio.

The Bankruptcy Case

In 1988, Espinosa was a baggage handler for America West Airlines when he began taking computer drafting classes at a technical school. Espinosa took out four student loans totaling over $13,000 from United Student Aid Funds.

After earning his degree, Espinosa was unable to find work in the computers field, and continued working at America West. However, that company was facing its own financial strain, and began cutting salaries. In 1992, Espinosa, a college graduate earning $6 an hour, filed bankruptcy.

According to the NPR story, Espinosa agreed to repay the full amount of the student loan debt through a three-to-five year Chapter 13 plan—but not the $4,000 of interest accrued on the loan. USAF was notified several times of the terms of the plan, and never objected to the case.

In 1997, the bankruptcy court declared Espinosa's debt repaid, and issued him a debt discharge.

However, two years later, USAF issued a lien on Espinosa's tax return for the unpaid interest. USAF claimed that the bankruptcy plan was illegal—11 years after the court confirmed it—because of the undue hardship requirement.

Undue Hardship Hearing Never Held

The student loan company argues that the bankruptcy court should have held a special hearing to determine whether Espinosa's situation qualified as an undue hardship, and should have summonsed USAF to appear in court. Because the hearing was never held, undue hardship was never established, and the loan should not have been dischargeable, USAF argued.

Espinosa's attorney has argued that USAF was properly notified and did not raise any objections at the time. A federal appeals court agreed.

Now it's up to the Supreme Court to decide just when a creditor can raise objection to a Chapter 13 bankruptcy plan—and when the can still collect on debts.

Guest Author: Peter Gomes

The real estate sector received a jolt when the sub-prime mortgage crisis eroded the US economy. The mortgage market was in doldrums and the upheaval so great that the government had to intervene with its series of mortgage bailout programs.

Consumers bankruptcy filings increased, and so did the number of foreclosures. Many Americans considering bankruptcy filing received >more information on bankruptcy by connecting with a bankruptcy attorney.

The Obama Administration introduced a series of mortgage bailout programs to assist homeowners facing foreclosure. The program, known as the Making Home Affordable Plan, was expected to help as many as 7 million to 9 million homeowners. However, due to few limitations, the program has yet to help as many homeowners as anticipated.

There is a vicious cycle of debt that has led to the recession, which has affected consumer spending as well as investor sentiment.

In the easy-credit boom, people started using their credit cards even for making payments for grocery shopping and for utility bills. As employers went on a cost cutting and job cutting spree, it became difficult for consumers to make ends meet.

For consumers considering filing bankruptcy, it can be Chapter 7 bankruptcy or Chapter 13 bankruptcy. In Chapter 7 bankruptcy, a court-appointed trustee will liquidate your non-exempt assets so that the proceeds can help in paying off creditors. As per the new federal bankruptcy laws, certain changes have been introduced. The prominent ones are Means test and credit counseling.

If you are planning to file Chapter 7 bankruptcy, you have to find out if you qualify for the same by taking the Means test. Consumers also must take a credit counseling session prior to filing bankruptcy.

In case of Chapter 13 bankruptcy, you are given a repayment schedule according to which you are expected to make payments to your creditors.

In either bankruptcy chapter, there is one advantage of filing: an Automatic Stay or Order for Relief that prevents creditors from coming after you for their dues.

Tuesday, September 29th, 2009

5 Reasons to File Chapter 13

This guest blog entry was written by David Chang of Chang & Carlin, LLP. Chang & Carlin offer bankruptcy and real estate legal services for Chicago and its suburbs. Read David Chang's blog at http://changandcarlin.blogspot.com

Many debtors view Chapter 7 bankruptcy as the "better" type of bankruptcy to file, and that Chapter 13 is forced upon them by the courts. However, filing bankruptcy under Chapter 13 has many benefits.

Here are 5 major reasons why people may choose file for Chapter 13 bankruptcy:

  1. Chapter 13 has protections designed to stop a foreclosure or repossession.
  2. Chapter 13 bankruptcy can protect an asset that would otherwise not be protected in Chapter 7, and would be sold to pay creditors.
  3. The debtor makes too much money to file for Chapter 7, and would not be able to file otherwise.
  4. The debtor has recently had debts discharged in a Chapter 7 case and is not eligible to file again.
  5. Chapter 13 can consolidate debts that would not be dischargeable in a typical Chapter 7 bankruptcy case.

In what many consider an inevitable shift in the foreclosure crisis, prime, fixed-rate mortgages made up the largest portion of new foreclosures, according to a report issued by the Mortgage Bankers Association.

This was the first time for such numbers since the subprime lending boom began.

The Best-Laid Plans

Sources suggest that two major factors are contributing to the upswing in prime foreclosures:

  • Rising Unemployment: Though the unemployment rate for those with some type of college degree is 4.4 percent (compared with an 8.9 percent rate overall), this number represents a significant jump from a year ago, when unemployment among the college-educated was just 2 percent. This means that some families who counted on sustained income to keep their houses are now struggling to make payments – or finding they cannot.
  • A Glut of Unsold Homes: Because so many houses are currently on the market, selling a house has become a serious challenge, especially for those with bigger mortgages. This means that many of those struggling to pay off debts because of job loss cannot even raise money by selling their houses – the demand for real estate is currently very low.

Time to Buy, Not Sell

As you may already know, it’s a great time to buy a first home.

The sheer quantity of homes on the market means you’ll have a lot to choose from, and the current interest rates favor the purchasers rather than the vendors.

But if you’re looking to sell a larger (rather than a “starter”) home, you may not be so lucky.

Those who may be pushed by tantalizing interest rates to buy a home sooner than they would have otherwise likely won’t be interested in large, elaborate homes – especially in light of the cautionary tales told over and over by those suffering from the current foreclosure crisis.

When Will It All End?

Experts have predicted a variety of timetables for the prime foreclosure crisis.

The least optimistic among these put the crest two years for now, with steady foreclosure action well into 2012.

And Making Home Affordable, the foreclosure-prevention plan introduced by the Obama administration has reportedly only helped about 17,000 homeowners to date – far fewer than the seven to nine million who could benefit from the program, according to its Web site.

If you’re concerned about losing your home to foreclosure, it may be time to speak with one of our sponsoring bankruptcy lawyers about filing bankruptcy.

Chapter 13 bankruptcy designed to stop foreclosure. Talk to a bankruptcy attorney about filing bankruptcy.

Wednesday, May 13th, 2009

Foreclosures Rise Again in April

According to the latest report from RealtyTrac, foreclosures jumped again in April.

CNNMoney.com reports that 342,000 U.S. homes received default or auction notices or were in the process of bank repossession last month.

This translates to one in every 324 U.S. homes involved in some part of the foreclosure process, a number which represents a one percent increase from March and a whopping 32 percent increase from the same time last year.

Here are some hard numbers that paint a picture of how serious this news is for American homeowners:

  • April numbers are the highest ever recorded by RealtyTrac in more than four years of monitoring such figures.
  • Since the start of the real estate bust cycle in August of ’07, more than 1.3 million homes have been foreclosed upon.
  • RealtyTrac’s original forecast of 3.4 million foreclosure filings for 2009 will likely be revised upward after April’s statistics.
  • Though foreclosures are a problem nationwide, 10 states were home to 75 percent of all filings (California, Florida, Nevada, Arizona, Illinois, Ohio, Michigan, Georgia, Texas and Virginia).

Dipping Home Prices Compound the Problem

Some experts are concerned about the effect falling home values will have on future foreclosure rates.

As housing prices keep decreasing, more and more borrowers find themselves “under water” on their mortgages (they owe more than their homes are worth).

This has reportedly led to an increase in people simply walking away from their homes and handing their keys over to the bank, and will likely mean missed payments and defaults for those who choose to stay.

Bank Repossessions Down – For Now

April’s bank repossession numbers actually decreased 11 percent from March, according to sources.

But this isn’t a trend that’s likely to continue: bank repossession is the last stop on the foreclosure train, and as more and more houses enter foreclosure proceedings, more and more will have to complete them in the future.

Chapter 13 Bankruptcy & Foreclosure

If you are one of the many Americans facing the threat of foreclosure, filing for Chapter 13 bankruptcy may provide you some of the relief you need.

Thanks to the protection of the automatic stay, all creditor collection actions (including garnishment, repossession and foreclosure) are typically halted for the duration of your case.

Many bankruptcy filers find that Chapter 13’s three- to five-year repayment plan offers them the time and breathing room they need to get current on their mortgages or at least make alternate living arrangements.

Sometimes, one traumatic life event causes another – as when a serious illness, injury or divorce pushes you to file for bankruptcy.

Bankruptcy after divorce can be tricky to understand, largely because both involve complex legal systems. Here are the basics of what happens in a bankruptcy after a divorce:

No Joint Filing Bankruptcy Petitions after Divorce

Once you and your spouse are legally divorced, you no longer have the option of filing a joint bankruptcy petition. But, depending on which chapter of bankruptcy you choose, one spouse’s filing could still affect the other.

Filing Divorce: The Division of Debts and Assets

As you probably know, divorces usually involve a division of marital property and debts between the divorcing parties. Depending on the laws in your state, you and your spouse will take responsibility for various debts and possession of various belongings.

The Chapter 7 Debt Discharge

The bankruptcy court does not always recognize the designations of the divorce court, though.

If one spouse files for Chapter 7 bankruptcy and receives a discharge for a debt that was jointly held during the marriage, creditors may have legal recourse to collect that debt from the other spouse.

The Chapter 13 Repayment Plan

The Chapter 13 repayment plan often allows bankruptcy filers to protect cosigners (and co-debtors) who have not filed a bankruptcy petition. Because many debts are eventually repaid in Chapter 13 bankruptcy, the likelihood that the other spouse would have to take on responsibility for a debt is typically lower in Chapter 13.

But Keep in Mind...

Although bankruptcy offers financial relief for many types of debt, some debt cannot be discharged by the bankruptcy court, such as:

• Alimony/spousal maintenance
• Child support
• Most student loans
• Most tax debt
• DUI & other criminal penalties and fines

If you’re worried about being able to afford child support and/or alimony payments (for example, because of a recent reduction in your income), you may be better off consulting with your divorce attorney about modifying the terms of your divorce than filing for bankruptcy.

However, bankruptcy can offer you relief by excusing you from other, less essential debts and thus freeing up more of your money to put toward the maintenance of your children and former spouse.

As always, consider seeking legal counsel before proceeding with bankruptcy, either before or after a divorce case.