Posts Tagged ‘corporate bankruptcy’

Wednesday, August 24th, 2011

The Bankruptcy Option for Countrywide

In 2008, Bank of America acquired Countrywide Financial, a mortgage lending company that was heavily involved in subprime lending practices during the housing boom. Since the merger between the two companies, Countrywide has proven a costly addition to the Bank of America brand.

Since 2008, according to The New York Times, Countrywide has cost Bank of American tens of billions of dollars in legal fees in addition to other significant losses.

Now, media outlets are throwing around the question of whether or not Countrywide might attempt a bankruptcy filing to help ease some of its debt. Here’s a look at what some insiders are saying.

Business Bankruptcy Rules

If an individual was losing as much money as Bank of America, she would likely need bankruptcy protection. But businesses have different considerations and are governed by different laws than individuals. Consider these.

  • Limited liability: One key element that might affect whether or not Bank of America chooses bankruptcy for Countrywide is whether it’s considered liable for the company’s losses. Business mergers commonly include provisions that limit the legal responsibility shareholders (and the other business) have for the acquired business’s debt. If these laws apply, Bank of America may not need bankruptcy for Countrywide.
  • Consolidation transactions: But there’s a chance the limited liability laws won’t apply in Bank of America’s case. That’s because the bank apparently engaged in a series of complicated transactions upon its acquisition of Countrywide to transfer its profits and debts to various subsidiaries.
  • Acquisition of notes and debt: In addition to the consolidation moves, Bank of America also reportedly took on some of Countrywide’s debt and assets. This further complicates the question of whether or not Countrywide remains separate enough from Bank of America to qualify for bankruptcy on its own.

Many of the complex manipulations between Bank of America and Countrywide came to light when insurance giant AIG filed a lawsuit against the bank insisting that it is liable for the mortgage lender’s debts.

At its heart, the question of bankruptcy is one of separation and commingling. Think of it this way: Countrywide’s financial distress could have been, to Bank of America, like a frostbitten limb. If amputated in time, the rest of the body could have been saved.

But because Bank of America reportedly allowed its healthy parts to mix with the troubled parts, separating the bad stuff from the good stuff might not be so simple. Many analysts have suggested that, because of the complexity of the maneuver, bankruptcy for Countrywide is an unlikely option.

Mortgage-Related Bankruptcy for Individuals

Unfortunately, the potential bankruptcy of Countrywide holds no real poetic justice for those who turned to bankruptcy because of unaffordable subprime mortgages. Rather, the financial faltering of an entity as large as Bank of America is just another symptom of a woebegone economy whose problems started in the housing market.

Wednesday, November 11th, 2009

The Year of the Prepackaged Bankruptcy

2009 has seen a dramatic rise in so-called prepackaged bankruptcy filings that streamline the bankruptcy process for large companies, according to a recent report from Reuters.

Companies filing for traditional bankruptcy can find themselves going through several years of Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing, which can interrupt business and create uncertainty.

Instead, in a prepackaged bankruptcy, companies can agree upon and arrange reorganization plans with their creditors before actually filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy. Creditors have sometimes even voted on the prepackaged plan before it is filed.

The prepackaged bankruptcy is a form of agreement that is even more accelerated than a pre-negotiated bankruptcy in which companies and creditors agree on some but not all stipulations of the plan.

Prepackaged Plans Increase 300 Percent

There have been 30 prepackaged bankruptcies this year, the Reuters report notes—a 300% increase from just 10 such arrangements in 2008. With 164 companies that have public equity and debt who have filed for Chapter 11, the prepackaged bankruptcies represent 18% of the total number filed.

The much-publicized CIT Group Inc bankruptcy was arranged with a prepackaged bankruptcy agreement, as were those of other troubled companies like Six Flags Inc, Charter Communications Inc, Panolam Industries International Inc and Lear Corp. According to Reuters, the 30 prepackaged bankruptcies in 2009 represent some $124 billion in assets.

Fast Filings in Prepackaged Bankruptcy

With the prepackaged bankruptcy, companies can turn around a Chapter 11 filing in a matter of months, even when dealing with a huge company like CIT and its $80 billion in assets, which expects approval of its bankruptcy filing in December, a mere month after filing.

The results are less uncertainty about what the terms of the bankruptcy will be, and less disruption of the business in question.

Six Flags Inc, the world’s largest regional theme park operator, filed for bankruptcy in mid-2009, and continues to negotiate a finalized plan. Robert Rossiter, the Chief Executive of Lear Corp., which makes automotive seats and electronics, recently said in a statement that Lear Corp. had moved through the financial restructuring process without missing a beat operationally.

According to Reuters, the traditional Chapter 11 filing, without a prepackaged bankruptcy, is now often referred to as a free fall.

Wednesday, September 23rd, 2009

10 Companies that Could Face Bankruptcy

Last week, Yahoo Finance had an interesting article about 10 big companies with troubled finances.

Citing a report by Audit Integrity, an independent corporate accounting researcher, these 10 publicly traded companies had the highest probability of declaring bankruptcy. Like many of their American customers, these companies may be seeing less income coming in and debts that just won't shrink. On the list:

  • Hertz: financing a fleet of new models while consumers cut travel and spending.
  • Sprint Nextel: phone customers are fleeing for rival carriers with more popular "smart phone" models.
  • Macy's: customers are shying away from higher-end department stores in favor of more affordable shopping.
  • CBS: TV advertising dollars aren't what they used to be, and CBS's difficulty may be a sign that other broadcasters could lose their footing as well.

Whether or not any of these companies end up filing bankruptcy remains to be seen. Signs of economic recovery could find investors sighing with relief.

Corporate Bankruptcy Chapters

Like consumers, businesses typically have two options when filing bankruptcy: Chapter 7 bankruptcy and Chapter 11 bankruptcy.

Chapter 7 bankruptcy for corporations works like chapter 7 personal bankruptcy, in which assets are sold, or liquidated, to repay creditors.

Chapter 11 bankruptcy is similar to chapter 13 for consumers, in which corporation enter a structured plan to repay creditors over time.