Posts Tagged ‘new bankruptcy law’

Senator Edward M. Kennedy will be remembered for his contributions to a wide variety of issues, including his tireless advocacy for health-care reform, but the late Senator from Massachusetts also played a crucial role in the bankruptcy reform law of 2005, an infamous piece of legislation that made it more difficult to abuse the benefits of filing bankruptcy.

Peter Edmondston of The New York Times says that Kennedy’s contribution to the bill was typical of his populist philosophy.

As the passage of the bankruptcy “reform” plan became inevitable, Senator Kennedy inserted a provision on the bigger bill that was designed to stop large corporations in bankruptcy from handing out big bonuses to employees.

Bankruptcy in the Corporate World

The provision has withstood several court cases so far, and more can be expected as more corporations find themselves filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy.

During his 18-minute speech in support of the change, Kennedy said that the Senate as a whole was “blatantly ignoring the real abuses in our bankruptcy laws: the corporate abuses that have become epidemic in recent years.”

He went on to call corporate bankruptcy law in the United States “grossly inadequate,” and criticizes the fact that the proposed 500-page bill did nothing to address this deficiency.

Key Employee Retention Plans

Kennedy’s amendment banned a common type of bankruptcy bonus program known as the “key employee retention plan,” or KERP.

So far, the KERP restriction program has gotten mixed reviews. Some believe that bankruptcy attorneys can sidestep KERP limitations by simply renaming the pay packages or making them available for those who meet very “low-bar” performance options or goals.

Rep. John Conyers of Michigan said in 2007 that despite Senator Kennedy’s “laudable efforts, creative practitioners have developed ways around the code’s restrictions.”

Others say that KERP has done a good job of requiring many corporate bonus programs to be based on real performance-related achievements. In 2006, a bankruptcy judge overseeing a Chapter 11 bankruptcy case rejected an initial bonus plan for top executives.

When explaining his decision, the judge cited the Kennedy amendment. That judge later approved bonuses for the same executives after a “modification” of the terms involved in the program.

Business Bankruptcy's Effects

Kennedy believed that rewarding individuals who have driven a company to a costly financial reorganization cost taxpayers’ money, pushed many workers out of jobs, and represented an unsupportable position in the face of the worst economy since the Great Depression.

As more such cases make their way through the courts and executives again feel bold enough to offer retention packages designed to keep their “best employees,” the true durability of Senator Kennedy’s contribution to the Bankruptcy Reform Act of 2005 will be put to the test.

Thursday, February 5th, 2009

Was 2008 the Year of the Bankruptcy?

Times are indeed tough—more than one million Americans filed Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 bankruptcy last year.

As the U.S. economy sunk, the number of Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 bankruptcies rose 33 percent, according to data from U.S. bankruptcy courts compiled by bankruptcy data firm, Automated Access to Court Electronic Records.

Bankruptcy data shows there were 819,115 personal bankruptcy filings in the U.S. during 2007.

In 2008, that number rose to 1,086,130. While the number of bankruptcy filings in 2008 falls far short of the record 2.1 filings in 2005, it’s still a significant increase.

The number of U.S. personal bankruptcies in 2008 was the highest since the new bankruptcy law went into effect.

The Reason for the 2005 “Bankruptcy Rush”

In 2005, many consumers raced to file Chapter 7 bankruptcy before the bankruptcy reform law took effect.

After BAPCPA took effect, it became more expensive to file bankruptcy and some people weren’t eligible to file Chapter 7, making Chapter 13 bankruptcy more appealing to some.

Some States Hit Harder Than Others

Although the number of bankruptcy filings increased everywhere, some areas of the country seemed to be hit harder by the recession.

The greatest increases in per capita bankruptcy filings were seen in Nevada, Delaware, California, Rhode Island and Florida, where the effects of the collapse of the housing market, mass layoffs and a generally poor economy were particularly pronounced.

For the second year in a row, Tennessee had the highest per capita rate of personal bankruptcy filings.

Texas saw an increase of only 1,500 more Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 bankruptcies, making it the state with the smallest increase in bankruptcy filings.

When the U.S. housing market collapsed and foreclosures began to sweep the nation, many blamed predatory lenders, while others felt no sympathy for homeowners who took mortgages they couldn't afford.

There's been a lot of finger pointing and plenty of blame to go around as the economic recession deepens.

According to The Kansas City Star, three researchers at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York are now putting some of the blame on The Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act of 2005.

Did the New Bankruptcy Law Spawn the Foreclosure Crisis?

The 2005 bankruptcy act was pushed hard by the credit card industry and researchers argue that the law shifted risk from credit card lenders to mortgage lenders, thus spawning the foreclosure crisis.

Prior to the new bankruptcy law, debtors were able to have their unsecured debts discharged by filing Chapter 7 bankruptcy.

After debts such as credit cards and medical bills were erased, they could then apply their earnings to their mortgages.

With the new bankruptcy law came the means test, which excluded many debtors from filing Chapter 7 bankruptcy, which discharges unsecured debts, and forced them into Chapter 13 bankruptcy, which allows more time to catch up on debts but does not discharge debts.

Researchers argue that people who could have previously filed Chapter 7 bankruptcy and saved their homes are now more likely to face foreclosure.

New Bankruptcy Law Did Fuel Foreclosures: The Argument

Donald P. Morgan, a research officer at the New York Fed was the paper's lead author.

Morgan told The Kansas City Star that he was "99 percent confident" that the bankruptcy reform act of 2005 is a primary cause of the nationwide foreclosure crisis and free-falling home prices.

According to The National Association of Realtors, the average sale price of an existing home fell 12.3 percent, to $224,200, over the 12 months ending in November.

Morgan and the co-authors of the paper say that the tougher requirements imposed by the bankruptcy reform act have caused an increase in the number of homeowners who default on their mortgages or walk away from their homes rather than filing bankruptcy.

A group of academic experts studied 2007 bankruptcy data and found that debtors who have avoided filing bankruptcy in recent years seem to be ordinary people in financial distress and not the high-income debtors that the bankruptcy reform act was intended to exclude.

A growing number of experts say that families currently filing bankruptcy owe more debt than ever before and are simply unable to manage it all with their limited disposable income.

The Bankruptcy and Foreclosure Numbers

The Government Accountability Office reported that through the second quarter of 2008, more than 4 percent of mortgages were in foreclosure or more than 90 days past due.

This marks the highest reported levels of mortgage defaults in the 29 years that the Mortgage Bankers Association has been keeping such records.

Will Bankruptcy Legislation Help?

New legislation may be the key to slowing the rate of foreclosures.

The bankruptcy cram-down legislation, if signed into law, could help the mortgage crisis by giving borrowers more of an advantage and encouraging voluntary arrangements between borrowers and lenders.

If an agreement cannot be reached between the borrower and the lender, bankruptcy judges would be given the power to alter the terms of the mortgage.

American businesses and individuals filed 108,595 bankruptcies, which is up 13 percent from September according to a Bloomberg article.

October was the first month that more than 100,000 bankruptcies were filed since the bankruptcy law changed.

In 2005, right before the new bankruptcy law passed, a record 2.1 million people filed for bankruptcy protection.

The historic numbers were credited to people trying to clear their debts before the new law went into effect because it established stricter requirements for people seeking bankruptcy relief.

Since then, the numbers have steadily been rising each year. In 2006, there were 590,500 bankruptcy filings and, in 2007, there were 827,000 filings.

It is expected that there will be at least 1.1 million bankruptcy filings by the end of 2008. (For the first ten months of 2008, the daily rate of bankruptcy filings is at 4,284—with that number we’ll hit 1,080,000 filings for the 2008 calendar year.)

Is Filing Bankruptcy an Option For You?

Although the new bankruptcy law did establish new prerequisites and requirements to filing bankruptcy, most people still qualify to file bankruptcy.

If you’re considering filing bankruptcy and want to know if you are eligible, consider talking to a bankruptcy lawyer today.